Canadian Librarians [August 2005] Responding to e-mailed enquiries from Gabriele Lundeen, chairwoman of the BPC's Freedom of Expression Committee, seven Canadian librarians reported challenges to the following publications in public libraries throughout 200405. The publications included a newspaper, books and videos:
| Title |
Author(s) or Editor(s) |
Publication Description |
Location of Library |
Complaint |
Result |
| Best of Drawn and Quarterly |
Chris Oliveros (editor) |
Adult graphic book |
Toronto Public Library |
It "contains sex and violence." |
Unreported |
| Cable: The End |
David Tischman and Darko Macan |
Young adult graphic novel |
Okanagan Regional Library System |
It contains "disturbing language"; it "should not be in the young adult area." |
Unreported |
| Daddy's Roommate |
Michael Willhoite |
Children's fiction |
Lethbridge Public Library |
It is "not a proper role model for children." |
Retained in collection |
| Famous Fred |
John Coates and Catrin Unwin (producers) |
Video-recording |
Kitchener Public Library |
Unreported |
Unreported |
| Final Exit |
Derek Humphry |
Non-fiction book |
Lethbridge Public Library |
It "promotes suicide." |
Retained in collection |
| Hitler's War |
David Irving |
Non-fiction book |
Kitchener Public Library |
Unreported |
Unreported |
| How Did I Begin? |
Mick Manning and Brita Granstrom |
Sex education book |
Okanagan Regional Library System |
It provides "too much information" about sex for young children. |
Unreported |
| Look-Alikes |
Joan Steiner |
A series of children's activity books |
Mississauga Library System |
They contain pictures of "cigarettes and guns." |
Retained in collection for circulation |
| The New York City Bartender's Joke Book |
Jimmy Pritchard |
Paperback book |
Saskatoon Public Library |
It "promotes negative attitudes toward women and ethnic minorities." |
Withdrawn from circulation |
| NOW |
Michael Hollett and Alice Klein (editors) |
Weekly newspaper in Toronto |
Mississauga Library System |
The complainant requested the removal of this free newspaper from the library. |
Retained for free weekly distribution |
| Paul Kagame and Rwanda: Power, Genocide and the Rwandan Patriotic Front |
Colin M. Waugh |
Non-fiction book |
Frost Library, York University, Toronto |
The complaining student's family was murdered in Rwanda in 1994. |
Removed from display but retained in collection |
| Porn Star: The Legend of Ron Jeremy |
Scott J. Gill (director) |
Video-recording |
Mississauga Library System |
Unreported |
Retained in collection for circulation |
| Sleeping Beauty |
Anne Rice |
A series of sexually explicit novels |
Okanagan Regional Library System |
The complainant requested a warning label for the series and suggested controlled access for readers under 18. |
Unreported |
| The Story of Little Black Sambo |
Helen Bannerman |
Children's fiction |
Okanagan Regional Library System |
The book contains the words "black" and "Sambo." The book is "insulting and racist." |
Retained in the advanced picture book section for children (aged 612 years) |
| Tadpole |
Gary Winick (director) |
Video-recording |
Kitchener Public Library |
Unreported |
Unreported |
| The Winter Rescue |
Paul Hutchens |
Christian fiction |
Okanagan Regional Library System |
The book conveys religious intolerance: "Christian is good; non-Christian is bad." |
Unreported |
This list is not exhaustive.